EMC Part 11. How to Distinguish Noise Source from Capacitive E-field / Inductive H-field Coupling.
EMC playlist. Watch these video to understand more on EMC.
• EMC Part 1. ElectroMagnetic Compatibi...
Distinguish E or H-field Coupling
Identifying whether noise is from an electric or a magnetic field involves understanding the characteristics of each type of field and using appropriate measurement techniques. Here are some steps and methods to distinguish between the two:
1. Understand the Nature of Electric and Magnetic Fields
Electric Field Noise: This is usually caused by voltage differences from high-impedance sources, often manifesting as capacitive coupling and influenced by nearby conductors or insulators.
Magnetic Field Noise: This is usually caused by current flow and can be generated by low-impedance sources. It often manifests as inductive coupling and is influenced by nearby loops or coils.
It may be useful to note some differences between inductive and capacitive coupling:
For inductive coupling (magnetic field coupling), a noise voltage is produced in series with the receptor conductor, whereas for capacitive coupling (electric field coupling), a noise current is produced between the receptor conductor and ground.
This difference can be used in the following test to distinguish between electric or magnetic coupling:
Measure the noise voltage across the impedance at one end of the cable while decreasing the impedance at the opposite end of the cable. If the measured noise voltage decreases, the pickup is electric, and if the measured noise voltage increases, the pickup is magnetic.
For inductive coupling (magnetic field coupling), a noise voltage is produced in series with the receptor conductor.
Measure the noise voltage across the impedance at one end of the cable while decreasing the impedance at the opposite end of the cable. If the measured noise voltage increases, the pickup is magnetic.
For capacitive coupling (electric field coupling), a noise current is produced between the receptor conductor and ground.
Measure the noise voltage across the impedance at one end of the cable while decreasing the impedance at the opposite end of the cable. If the measured noise voltage decreases, the pickup is electric
2. Use Appropriate Sensors and Instruments
Electric Field Sensors: Use a high-impedance probe or electric field meter to measure electric field noise. These sensors are sensitive to voltage changes and can detect electric fields in the environment.
Magnetic Field Sensors: Use a loop antenna, a Hall effect sensor, or a magnetic field meter to measure magnetic field noise. These sensors are sensitive to current changes and can detect magnetic fields.
3. Analyze the Frequency Spectrum
Electric Field Noise: Often appears at higher frequencies and can be broadband or narrowband, depending on the source.
Magnetic Field Noise: Often appears at lower frequencies, especially if it is related to power line frequencies (50/60 Hz) or harmonics thereof.
4. Observe the Directionality
Electric Field Noise: Can be directional and is often influenced by the orientation of the sensor relative to the source.
Magnetic Field Noise: Also directional, but the orientation of the sensor (e.g., a loop antenna) will affect the measurement differently compared to an electric field sensor.
5. Check for Sources
Electric Field Sources: Look for sources like high-voltage power lines, fluorescent lights, or electronic devices with high-impedance outputs.
Magnetic Field Sources: Look for sources like transformers, motors, or any device with significant current flow.
6. Use Shielding Techniques
Electric Field Shielding: Use conductive materials (e.g., copper or aluminum foil) to shield against electric fields. If the noise decreases significantly, it is likely electric field noise.
Magnetic Field Shielding: Use high-permeability materials (e.g., mu-metal) to shield against magnetic fields. If the noise decreases significantly, it is likely magnetic field noise.
7. Conduct Differential Measurements
Electric Field: Measure the noise with and without a grounded shield. A significant reduction indicates electric field noise.
Magnetic Field: Measure the noise with and without a magnetic shield. A significant reduction indicates magnetic field noise.
8. Consult the Environment
Electric Field: More likely in environments with high-voltage equipment or static electricity.
Magnetic Field: More likely in environments with heavy machinery, transformers, or large current-carrying conductors.
9. Use Simulation Tools
Electric Field: Use electromagnetic simulation software to model electric fields and predict noise sources.
Magnetic Field: Use the same tools to model magnetic fields and predict noise sources.